We are now entering the heart of literary award season — the League of Canadian Poets just announced the winners of its set of awards, the Griffin Poetry Prize will be awarded this week and the Trilliums next week — which means we’re also entering the season of complaining about literary awards.
The general arc of complaints tend to go something like this: “That person shouldn’t have won because his/her book is [adjective]. This book should have won instead because it’s much more [different adjective].”
These reactions aren’t surprising, and we cannot reasonably expect a three-person jury’s choice to line up with our own aesthetic most (or even some) of the time.